June 16th, 2011

Grand jury finds workplace bullying a problem within county government

In Ventura County just south of lovely Santa Barbara, California, a remarkable and unusual thing happened. A grand jury (GJ) was convened to act like consultants contracted to investigate complaints (one of their roles in that county) about workplace bullying by current and former county workers. The GJ as investigator concluded that bullying is a problem and employees deserve protection from it. An investigation conducted by HR might have concluded differently (as it nearly always does). The GJ reported that HR procedures are not trusted. Said the county HR director, John Nicoll, “We do not tolerate employees being mistreated because they’ve filed a complaint.” This directly contradicts facts in the GJ report. Note how outsiders found the truth about bullying.

Here’s the local newspaper account:

Grand jury finds workplace bullying a problem within county government by John Scheibe, Ventura County Star, June 16, 2011

The Ventura County Grand Jury recently concluded that workplace bullying is a problem in county government offices and encouraged county officials to develop a policy against bullying in the workplace.

“Unfortunately, bullying is not limited to schools,” the grand jury stated in a letter released in late May.
The 2010-11 grand jury investigated bullying within county government after getting a complaint about it. As part of this, the grand jury interviewed past and current county employees who were the targets of bullying or witnessed it.

John Nicoll, assistant county executive officer and the director of human resources for the county, said county officials are preparing a response to the grand jury’s report.

“We understand the concerns about conduct like that in the workplace,” Nicoll said.

Grand jurors found employees “were yelled at by managers in group meetings and in public areas.”
Also, employees, including some highly experienced ones, “were excessively monitored by managers to such an extent that they left their positions,” the grand jury’s report stated.

Some employees went to other agencies, while others accepted “a demotion to receive that transfer.”
Others left county government for other jobs or retired earlier than they had planned because of a “manager’s bullying behavior,” the grand jury found.

Some employees were isolated both “organizationally and physically,” the report stated.
The report found the county “has no written policy specifically directed against bullying in the workplace.”
It also found that processes to report workplace bullying “are not trusted by employees because the agency with the alleged bullying issue is allowed to investigate complaints using personnel within its own organization.”

Nicoll said there are mechanisms now in place for county employees to file a complaint if they believe they have been discriminated against.

As to the allegation by the grand jury that county employees have left their jobs because of workplace bullying, Nicoll said he “would be upset if someone were legitimately fleeing the workplace if they felt they were being mistreated” and felt they had no recourse but to leave.

“We do not tolerate employees being mistreated because they’ve filed a complaint,” Nicoll said. “I’m disappointed if someone left for that reason.”

Nicoll said he did not know how widespread a problem workplace bullying is in the county government.
However, he said “the county has gotten very limited number of complaints of inappropriate treatment by their supervisors.”

The Workplace Bullying Institute, a nonprofit organization dedicated to eradicating workplace bullying through research and education, commissioned a 2010 study that found 35 percent of workers in the United States have experienced bullying firsthand. Men constitute 62 percent of bullies, while women make up 58 percent of the targets of bullying, according to the study. Female bullies target other women 80 percent of the time, according to the study, done by Zogby International. The study found workplace bullying is a silent epidemic since many workers who are victims of it or witness it fail to report it.

The group, which is based in Washington state, defines workplace bullying as repeated, health-harming abusive conduct committed by bosses and co-workers against others. Workplace bullying is legal in many states across the nation, according to the institute. The institute is working to introduce bills in various state legislatures that would make workplace bullying illegal.

The institute also found that workplace bullying costs companies millions of dollars in employee turnover, lost productivity and lawsuits. The grand jury seemed to agree, stating in its report that workplace bullying costs taxpayers additional money because the county must incur the cost of recruiting and training replacement personnel for those who have left their jobs because of bullying. …

The grand jury is recommending the Ventura County Board of Supervisors issue a policy against bullying and collect data “to identify the existence and extent of bullying in branches of county government.”
Such a policy should include descriptions of bullying behaviors to educate employees on unacceptable workplace behaviors and encourage employees to report this type of workplace abuse, the grand jury said.




Solutions for Ventura County can be found in the book The Bully-Free Workplace and at the website for the premier workplace bullying consultants, The Work Doctor®


<-- Read the complete WBI Blog

Tags: , , , ,

This entry was posted on Thursday, June 16th, 2011 at 11:20 pm and is filed under Employers Gone Wild: Doing Bad Things, Rulings by Courts, WBI in the News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Having trouble? Click Here for Comments Guide

Facebook Comments


Disqus Comments

What Do You Think?

Just a short reminder that all blog comments are moderated and should be posted shortly.

  1. Beatrice Narvaez says:

    This article was a God sent for me, I have been off from work for almost three months on Medical Leave, suffering from many of the effects of being, bullied and pressured by my supervisor, and others in the same department in a government entity. I was preparing myself to retire from the entity, and move on. But, after reading this article, and being under the care of several doctors, I am stronger and ready to go back to my job! Plus, I now have WBI for educating me. I have signed up as an Advocate for WBI, I want to help others become aware of this issue, and preventing it from taking a life of a victim. A person can feel so worthless, and depressed after being bullied, making them want to take their own life. This problem needs to be addressed.

  2. Rosie says:

    Mr. Nicoll needs to wake up and start punishing the bullies whether they are management or not. Deputy Manager Sandra Bickford has been intimidating and bullying people for years. More than a handful of people have left the Auditor Controller’s office because of this, and Christine Cohen has been turning the other cheek for years while all this happened.

  3. Eric Gonchar says:

    Eric Gonchar

    Grand jury finds workplace bullying a problem within county government | Workplace Bullying Institute

What do You think?

Below is a comment box, we would love to hear any comments or concerns you have regarding this blog post.

For your personal safety please note than anything you write here is public and may show up in a search engine. Do not use any specific names or places if you are concerned for your privacy.

(Maximum characters: 4,000)
You have characters left.

This site is best viewed with Firefox web browser. Click here to upgrade to Firefox for free. X